02 Aug 25

Merstham

1 – 4

Carshalton Athletic

Friendlies Clubs

22 Jul 24

Carshalton Athletic

2 – 1

Merstham

Friendlies Clubs

22 Jul 23

Merstham

3 – 5

Carshalton Athletic

Friendlies Clubs

23 Apr 22

Merstham

1 – 2

Carshalton Athletic

Non League Premier - Isthmian

11 Dec 21

Carshalton Athletic

3 – 1

Merstham

Non League Premier - Isthmian

05 Apr 21

Carshalton Athletic

15:00

Merstham

Non League Premier - Isthmian

23 Mar 21

Merstham

19:45

Carshalton Athletic

Non League Premier - Isthmian

04 Nov 20

Merstham

1 – 3

Carshalton Athletic

FA Trophy

21 Dec 19

Carshalton Athletic

1 – 1

Merstham

Non League Premier - Isthmian

26 Oct 19

Carshalton Athletic

3 – 1

Merstham

FA Trophy