12 Apr 25

Carshalton Athletic

0 – 3

Horsham

Non League Premier - Isthmian

04 Jan 25

Horsham

3 – 0

Carshalton Athletic

Non League Premier - Isthmian

09 Mar 24

Horsham

1 – 2

Carshalton Athletic

Non League Premier - Isthmian

21 Oct 23

Carshalton Athletic

1 – 2

Horsham

Non League Premier - Isthmian

07 Jan 23

Carshalton Athletic

1 – 1

Horsham

Non League Premier - Isthmian

20 Aug 22

Horsham

1 – 3

Carshalton Athletic

Non League Premier - Isthmian

15 Feb 22

Horsham

2 – 2

Carshalton Athletic

Non League Premier - Isthmian

22 Nov 21

Carshalton Athletic

0 – 1

Horsham

Non League Premier - Isthmian

30 Oct 21

Horsham

2 – 3

Carshalton Athletic

FA Trophy

13 Mar 21

Horsham

15:00

Carshalton Athletic

Non League Premier - Isthmian

12 Oct 20

Carshalton Athletic

3 – 1

Horsham

Non League Premier - Isthmian

29 Feb 20

Carshalton Athletic

4 – 0

Horsham

Non League Premier - Isthmian