28 Feb 26

Potters Bar Town

2 – 1

Carshalton Athletic

Non League Premier - Isthmian

01 Nov 25

Carshalton Athletic

2 – 0

Potters Bar Town

Non League Premier - Isthmian

14 Feb 25

Potters Bar Town

0 – 1

Carshalton Athletic

Non League Premier - Isthmian

18 Nov 24

Carshalton Athletic

2 – 1

Potters Bar Town

Non League Premier - Isthmian

06 Feb 24

Potters Bar Town

1 – 1

Carshalton Athletic

Non League Premier - Isthmian

12 Aug 23

Carshalton Athletic

5 – 0

Potters Bar Town

Non League Premier - Isthmian

15 Apr 23

Potters Bar Town

3 – 1

Carshalton Athletic

Non League Premier - Isthmian

03 Dec 22

Carshalton Athletic

5 – 2

Potters Bar Town

Non League Premier - Isthmian

12 Mar 22

Carshalton Athletic

2 – 3

Potters Bar Town

Non League Premier - Isthmian

30 Nov 21

Potters Bar Town

1 – 2

Carshalton Athletic

Non League Premier - Isthmian

05 May 21

Potters Bar Town

19:45

Carshalton Athletic

Non League Premier - Isthmian

19 Sept 20

Carshalton Athletic

3 – 0

Potters Bar Town

Non League Premier - Isthmian

15 Feb 20

Carshalton Athletic

5 – 1

Potters Bar Town

Non League Premier - Isthmian