FT
FC Cincinnati
1
–
0
Louisville City
—
FT
FC Cincinnati
1
–
0
New York City FC
—
FT
New York Red Bulls
1
–
1
FC Cincinnati
—
FT
FC Cincinnati
3
–
1
Pittsburgh Riverhounds
—
FT
FC Cincinnati
3
–
3
Inter Miami
—
Faded rows: team matches without Brenner in the lineup