E. Finlay

FT

Colorado Rapids

2 – 0

Columbus Crew

Sub

FT

Columbus Crew

2 – 0

CF Montreal

Sub

FT

Toronto FC

0 – 1

Columbus Crew

Sub

FT

Columbus Crew

1 – 4

New York Red Bulls

Sub

FT

Philadelphia Union

1 – 0

Columbus Crew

Started

FT

Columbus Crew

2 – 2

Houston Dynamo

Sub

FT

Columbus Crew

0 – 1

Whitecaps

Sub

FT

Portland Timbers

0 – 0

Columbus Crew

Started

FT

Columbus Crew

2 – 1

FC Dallas

Started

FT

San Jose Earthquakes

1 – 1

Columbus Crew

—

FT

Seattle Sounders

0 – 2

Columbus Crew

—

FT

Columbus Crew

2 – 1

Chicago Fire

—

FT

New England Revolution

0 – 0

Columbus Crew

Sub

FT

Chicago Fire

2 – 1

Columbus Crew

Sub

FT

Columbus Crew

2 – 0

Real Salt Lake

—

FT

CF Montreal

2 – 1

Columbus Crew

—

FT

Columbus Crew

0 – 2

Sporting Kansas City

—

FT

Columbus Crew

1 – 0

DC United

Sub

FT

Sporting Kansas City

1 – 2

Columbus Crew

Sub

FT

DC United

1 – 0

Columbus Crew

Sub

FT

Columbus Crew

1 – 1

Los Angeles Galaxy

Sub

FT

Houston Dynamo

2 – 2

Columbus Crew

Sub

FT

Columbus Crew

2 – 1

Toronto FC

—

FT

Columbus Crew

4 – 3

New England Revolution

—

FT

Philadelphia Union

1 – 2

Columbus Crew

—

FT

Columbus Crew

2 – 1

CF Montreal

Sub

FT

New England Revolution

2 – 0

Columbus Crew

—

FT

New York Red Bulls

3 – 1

Columbus Crew

—

FT

Columbus Crew

1 – 0

Chivas USA

—

FT

Chicago Fire

2 – 1

Columbus Crew

—

FT

Columbus Crew

3 – 2

Philadelphia Union

—

FT

Columbus Crew

1 – 1

Sporting Kansas City

—

FT

DC United

3 – 2

Columbus Crew

—

FT

Columbus Crew

2 – 1

Toronto FC

—