FT
San Carlos
3
–
5
New York City FC
Sub
FT
New York City FC
1
–
0
San Carlos
—
FT
New York City FC
0
–
1
Tigres UANL
—
FT
Tigres UANL
4
–
0
New York City FC
—
Faded rows: team matches without J. Scally in the lineup