18 Apr 25

Horsham

3 – 0

Cray Wanderers

Non League Premier - Isthmian

07 Sept 24

Cray Wanderers

0 – 0

Horsham

Non League Premier - Isthmian

13 Apr 24

Horsham

2 – 0

Cray Wanderers

Non League Premier - Isthmian

16 Aug 23

Cray Wanderers

1 – 3

Horsham

Non League Premier - Isthmian

25 Mar 23

Cray Wanderers

5 – 3

Horsham

Non League Premier - Isthmian

22 Nov 22

Horsham

2 – 2

Cray Wanderers

Non League Premier - Isthmian

26 Feb 22

Horsham

2 – 2

Cray Wanderers

Non League Premier - Isthmian

08 Dec 21

Cray Wanderers

3 – 1

Horsham

Non League Premier - Isthmian

22 Apr 21

Horsham

19:45

Cray Wanderers

Non League Premier - Isthmian

01 Feb 20

Cray Wanderers

2 – 1

Horsham

Non League Premier - Isthmian

22 Oct 19

Horsham

1 – 1

Cray Wanderers

Non League Premier - Isthmian

07 Oct 17

Cray Wanderers

8 – 0

Horsham

FA Trophy